Category: Case Reports

Scleral Lens Management of Soft Contact Lens Induced Limbal Stem Cell Deficiency

[us_post_title][us_post_date][us_separator size=”small”]

By Fareedah Haroun, OD and Chantelle Mundy, OD, FAAO, FSLS

Introduction

Limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD) results in dysfunction and/or loss of the stem cells in the basal limbal area. These cells are responsible for maintaining and replenishing the corneal epithelium. This change in corneal tissue composition results in conjunctival epithelial ingrowth, persistent epithelial defects, chronic inflammation, and neovascularization.1,5 There are numerous conditions that lead to LSCD, and studies have found that about 15% of cases are a result of contact lens wear.4 Literature suggests that this may be due to mechanical trauma resulting from inadequate lens movement leading to increased friction, compression, and hypoxia. This case report aims to explore the use of scleral lenses to treat LSCD when conventional treatment measures do not improve a patient’s ocular surface.

Case Presentation

A 16-year-old female was referred by the corneal specialist for a scleral lens evaluation due to LSCD of the left eye. The patient participated in a monthly soft contact lens research study for six years and is believed to have developed LSCD secondary to the soft contact lens wear.

  • Chief complaint: blurred vision, light sensitivity, burning and excessive watering OS
  • Ocular history: LSCD OS, Myopia OU, Astigmatism OS
  • Ocular surgeries: None
  • Ocular medications: Artificial tears prn
 

Right

Left

Visual Acuity (cc-gls)

20/20-1 | 1.0

20/80-1 | 0.25

Intraocular Pressure

21 mmHg

21 mmHg

External

Normal

Normal

Lids/Lashes

Normal

Normal

Conjunctiva/Sclera

White and quiet

White and quiet

Cornea

Clear

Peripheral whorl-like haze extending from limbus – greatest superior, scattered punctate epithelial erosions

Anterior Chamber

Deep and quiet

Deep and quiet

Iris

Round and reactive

Round and reactive

Lens

Clear

Clear

Table 1. Entrance Testing and Slit Lamp Examination

Methods and Results

Initial Treatment Plan Prior to Referral:
  • Discontinue contact lens wear OU
  • Dry eye management OU
  • Preservative free artificial tears QID OU
  • Doxycycline 100mg BID x 7 days
  • Maxitrol QID OS
  • Alaway BID OU
Contact Lens Fitting:
  • OD: discontinue wear of monthly contact lens and refit into daily disposable soft contact lens
  • OS: fit into BostonSight® SCLERAL 16.5mm with a SmartChannel™
[us_separator size=”small”]
[us_image image=”10945″]
[us_image image=”10946″]
[us_separator size=”small”]
Figure 1. Scheimpflug tomography of the patient’s right and left eye taken prior to contact lens fitting.
[us_separator size=”small”]

Clinical Outcomes:

OD:

    • BCVA: 20/20
    • Well centered fit with adequate coverage and movement
    • No staining upon lens removal

OS:

    • BCVA: 20/20-
    • Complete resolution of whorl like peripheral haze after 2 months of wear, residual haze at the superior limbus
    • No staining upon lens removal
[us_separator size=”small”]

Eye

Brand

Lens

Base Curve

Diameter

Power

Material

Center Thickness

OD

Alcon

Dailies Total 1

8.50

14.1 mm

-4.00 DS

Delefilcon A

n/a

OS

BostonSight®

BostonSight® SCLERAL for Daily Wear

8.00

16.5 mm

-1.48 DS

Contamac Optimum Infinite with Plasma

0.300

Table 2. Final Contact Lens Parameters

 

Eye

Sphere

Cylinder

Axis

BCVA

OD

-4.25

-0.50

100

20/20

OS

-4.00

-0.75

057

20/20-1

Table 3. Final Manifest Refraction After 5 Months of Scleral Lens Wear

Discussion

Contact lens wear is a lesser known and often asymptomatic cause of LSCD. Most of the published literature suggests that the majority of these cases are due to soft contact lenses. Mechanical trauma is the primary reason for contact lens induced LSCD. This is mainly due to the friction that results as the eyelids push against the ocular surface during a blink. As a result, the eye becomes irritated and dry. If this happens chronically, damage to the limbal area results in stem cell dysfunction. Lens design and materials can also play a role by causing compression and hypoxia at the limbal area.4

Scleral lenses are an excellent management option for LSCD because they provide constant lubrication allowing the cornea to regenerate with minimal disruption. Scleral lenses protect the corneal surface from environmental stressors such as the mechanical trauma that may occur due to the eyelids. Studies have found that the majority of contact lens induced LSCD primarily impacts the superior limbal area. Therefore, superior haptic modifications should be considered to optimize the contact lens fit for these patients.4,5

LSCD can often be misdiagnosed for other conditions. Common misdiagnoses included superior limbic keratoconjunctivitis (SLK), chronic corneal epitheliopathy and corneal intraepithelial neoplasia. Our patient was initially diagnosed with SLK and treated with Maxitrol QID OS. However, SLK is typically bilateral and often has underlying systemic associations.4

[us_separator size=”small”][us_image image=”10948″ align=”center”][us_separator size=”small”]
Figure 2. This photo, taken by slit lamp external photography, shows our patient’s left lens at final dispense. The red lines outline the SmartChannel™ that was added to increase oxygenated tear exchange at the superior limbus. The channel is 30 degrees wide with a 0.15um depth.
[us_separator size=”small”][us_image align=”center” image=”10950″][us_separator size=”small”]
Figure 3. This photo, taken by slit lamp external photography, shows the patient’s ocular surface OS at their most recent follow up appointment. As you can see, the whorl-like fluorescein pattern has completely resolved leaving trace residual haze at the superior limbus.
[us_separator size=”small”]

Conclusion

Contact lens induced LSCD is multifactorial. Contact lenses disrupt the tear film, cause hypoxia and mechanical trauma leading to an inflammatory response.4

LSCD is typically bilateral and asymmetric, but in this case it was unilateral. The patient is at higher risk of developing LSCD in the fellow eye, so you must monitor it closely. To maximize our patient’s ocular health, we switched her into a daily disposable lens and monitored every few months.3

Ensuring that soft contact lenses are properly fit helps to minimize the risk of developing LSCD. As a fitter we should aim for lenses with a low modulus, high DK, and adequate movement (0.1mm-0.4mm). Keep in mind that, although popular, silicone hydrogel lenses have shown increased mechanical trauma due to the decreased flexibility needed to achieve increased oxygen permeability.2

Educate patients on wear schedules, emphasizing no extended or overnight wear. Pay special attention to those with steeper corneas and tighter lids because they are prone to more friction and damage due to inadequate lens movement.4

More conservative treatment options should be explored prior to using scleral lenses to manage LSCD. This typically begins with the cessation of contact lens wear, preservative-free artificial tears, lid hygiene, warm compresses, punctual plugs and other measures as indicated. To address possible inflammation, consider adding topical steroids and/or topical cyclosporine to the treatment plan.4

Surgical management may be considered when all other options are exhausted due to potential risks and complications. Surgical options include, but are not limited to, epithelial debridement, amniotic membrane transplantation and limbal stem cell transplantation.3

[us_separator show_line=”1″ size=”small”]
1. Cheung AY, Sarnicola E, Denny MR, Sepsakos L, Auteri NJ, Holland EJ. Limbal Stem Cell Deficiency: Demographics and Clinical Characteristics of a Large Retrospective Series at a Single Tertiary Referral Center. Cornea. 2021 Dec 1;40(12):1525-1531.
2. Dumbleton, Kathy M.Sc., M.C.Optom, F.A.A.O.. Noninflammatory Silicone Hydrogel Contact Lens Complications. Eye & Contact Lens: Science & Clinical Practice: January 2003 – Volume 29 – Issue 1 – p S186-S189
3. Lee SC, Hyon JY, Jeon HS. Contact Lens Induced Limbal Stem Cell Deficiency: Clinical Features in Korean Patients. Korean J Ophthalmol. 2019 Dec;33(6):500-505
4. Rossen J, Amram A, Milani B, Park D, Harthan J, Joslin C, McMahon T, Djalilian A. Contact Lens-induced Limbal Stem Cell Deficiency. Ocul Surf. 2016 Oct;14(4):419-434.
[us_separator show_line=”1″ size=”small”]
[us_separator size=”large”][us_image image=”10952″ size=”us_600_0″ has_ratio=”1″ ratio=”3×4″]
[us_separator size=”large”][us_separator]

Dr. Haroun, FAAO, completed her undergraduate degree at the University of Pittsburgh before pursuing her optometric training at The Ohio State University College of Optometry. She stayed in Columbus to complete a residency in Cornea, Contact Lens and Ocular Disease at The Ohio State University Department of Ophthalmology – Havener Eye Insitute. She is now a Clinical Assistant Professor at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center- Mercy Vision Insitute providing care for patients within the Specialty Contact Lens Clinic.

[us_separator size=”large”][us_image image=”10953″ size=”us_600_0″ has_ratio=”1″ ratio=”3×4″]
[us_separator size=”large”]

Dr. Mundy is a clinical associate professor at The Ohio State University Department of Ophthalmology and Visual Sciences. She is a graduate of The Ohio State University College of Optometry and completed an ocular disease-based residency at the Cincinnati Eye Institute. She is program director of the Cornea and Contact Lens residency program and clinical instructor for both optometry students and ophthalmology residents. She is a fellow of the Scleral Lens Education Society (SLS), a fellow in the American Academy of Optometry (AAO) a member of the American Optometric Association (AOA) and completed a PROSE clinical fellowship. Dr. Mundy is co-founder of the Advanced Specialty Contact Lens Clinic in the department and her interests include scleral lens fitting for advanced ocular surface and corneal disease. She received the 2022 Top Doc award from the National Keratoconus Foundation.

[us_separator size=”large”]
[us_separator size=”small” show_line=”1″]
[us_post_navigation in_same_term=”1″]
[us_sharing providers=”facebook,twitter,linkedin” align=”right”]
Tags: , , , , , , ,

Putting the Latest Soft Contact Lens Research to Practice

[us_post_title][us_post_date][us_separator size=”small”]

By Thibaud Syre

Introduction

In 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic wrought significant havoc on our healthcare system and daily lives. The implementation of public health measures, aimed at safeguarding the population, reshaped our professional landscape. We witnessed a surge in demand for contact lens fittings, coinciding with the return of our regular wearers seeking adjustments. These trends were primarily driven by the discomfort caused by mask-wearing, as well as the growing prevalence of remote work, which placed increased demands on near vision. Consequently, our workload escalated, necessitating the restructuring of our clinics for enhanced efficiency.

Concurrently, as our contact lens fitting consultations surged, we observed a swifter discontinuation of older contact lens models by some manufacturers. However, discontinuing a lens type also entails the responsibility of providing wearers with new models that cater to their vision and comfort requirements. In this demanding environment, characterized by heightened activity, we contemplate the possibility of unearthing valuable solutions through university research.

Case report

Allow me to illustrate how such research, requiring no additional equipment beyond what is already available in our clinics, could streamline the process of refitting long-time wearers while minimizing the time spent in the chair.

Consider the case of a 49-year-old male, a long-time contact lens wearer, who previously reported optimal comfort with his lenses:

Original Lens

OD -4.75 (-1.25) 130° Diam : 14.50 Bc : 8.50

OS -4.00 (-1.25) 90° Diam : 14.50 Bc : 8.50

Visual acuity was good with OD 20/20 (1.0) and OS 20/20 (ODS 20/20)

Fitting: Optimal, with excellent lens centering. A slight movement was observed during ocular versions, but a good return to the push-up position. Lens surface condition remained good after 11 hours of continuous wear.

However, the reason for his appointment was the lens type the patient was currently wearing successfully was going to be discontinued, necessitating the search for an alternative. He had already sought assistance from his longstanding fitter but without success.

Subsequently, we examined without lenses:

[us_separator size=”small”]
[us_image image=”10958″]
[us_image image=”10959″]
[us_separator size=”small”]
[us_image image=”10960″]
[us_image image=”10961″]
[us_separator size=”small”]

Trial (and error)

Here we find the trials done in the context of refit. It is important to note that these tests were repeated for the writing of this report, as we did not have access to the previous observations.

1st Trial Lens:

OD -4.75 (-1.25) 130° Diam : 14.50 Bc : 8.60

OS -4.00 (-1.25) 90° Diam : 14.50 Bc : 8.60

Result: Excessive lens movement and visual instability. The lenses cannot be worn longer than one hour.

2nd Trial Lens:

OD -4.75 (-1.25) 130° Diam : 14.50 Bc : 8.60

OS -4.00 (-1.25) 90° Diam : 14.50 Bc : 8.60

Result: Improved lens stability, but excessive movement persisted. The discomfort was reported after a few hours of wear, rendering this lens unsuitable as a substitute for the his previous lenses.

3rd Trial Lens:

OD -4.75 (-1.25) 130° Diam: 14.50 Bc: 8.70

OS -4.00 (-1.25) 90° Diam: 14.50 Bc: 8.70

Result: Even though the surface of this lens appeared to be greatly improved, the dynamic behavior remained unacceptable. The patient even noted that, during trials, the entire lens slid over the cornea.

Making a Change

In a fresh perspective on this refitting challenge, we turned to the latest research insights. In January 2021, van der Worp et al. introduced a CL-SAG analysis for today’s most popular soft lenses. Notably, the original lens design exhibited the highest SAG in the chart at 4157 µm. This aligns with historical practices of using this lens for steeper corneas specifically, as confirmed by this research.

It is therefore interesting to compare the previously used unsuccessful lenses with the CL-SAG value of his previous successful lens:

For the first trial lens, the SAG difference is 188 µm.

For the second trial lens, the SAG difference is 277 µm.

For the third trial lens, the SAG difference is 297 µm.

This correlation with clinical analysis is striking. Regardless of the radius of curvature and lens diameter (the only parameters easily accessible to the fitter), it is evident that the sagittal height of a soft lens significantly influences its behavior on the wearer’s eye.

With this revelation, we opted to select a lens with the closest SAG to the original lens. Consequently, we ordered the following lenses for trial:

4th Trial Lens:

OD -4.75 (-1.25) 130° Diam: 14.50 Bc: 8.40

OS -4.00 (-1.25) 90° Diam: 14.50 Bc: 8.40

According to van der Worp et al., the CL-SAG of the fourth trial lens is 4153 µm. Compared to the historical lens, the SAG difference is only 7 µm.

After one day’s wear, the patient reported regaining the comfort he had with his old lenses. The examination revealed a well-centered lens with good mobility and  movement back to the standard location was observed as is desired. The surface condition remained unchanged, even after extended wear and when the lenses are removed, fluorescein examination reveals no staining.

[us_separator size=”small”]
[us_image image=”10962″]
[us_image image=”10963″]
[us_separator size=”small”]
[us_image image=”10964″]
[us_image image=”10965″]
[us_separator size=”small”]

Closing Remarks

In summary, this case underscores how university research, utilizing existing clinic equipment, can rapidly identify a first-choice replacement lens. In this instance, it could have averted three unsuccessful trials, saving considerable consultation time. It also prompts us to reconsider our lens selection methodology, both initially and for optimization purposes. Moreover, this case report reaffirms that there is no direct correlation between the diameter/base curve and the actual behavior of the worn lens on-eye.

This also prompts us to reconsider the significance of made-to-order soft contact lenses, which continue to be an effective tool for controlling the sagittal heights of the fitted lenses. In this case, we prescribed a daily replacement lens, another option would have been to consider a customised soft lens that matched the SAG of the original lens.

It would therefore be interesting to pursue this work to complete the lens types analyzed with new lenses that come to the market and facilitate the use of this work at a time when the notions of sagittal height are gaining more attention with the increasing popularization of scleral lens fitting.

[us_separator show_line=”1″ size=”small”]
1. van der Worp E, Lampa M, Kinoshita B, Fujimoto MJ, Coldrick BJ, Caroline P. Variation in sag values in daily disposable, reusable and toric soft contact lenses. Cont Lens Anterior Eye. 2021;44(6):101386. doi:10.1016/j.clae.2020.11.006

[us_separator show_line=”1″ size=”small”]
[us_image image=”10967″ size=”us_600_0″ has_ratio=”1″ ratio=”3×4″]

Thibaud SYRE, co-founder of AlpesVision, an advanced optometry clinic located in Grenoble, is an expert in specialty contact lenses, with particular attention on orthokeratology and scleral lenses. He is a member of various organizations such as the French Association of Contact Lens Experts, the Scleral Lens Education Society, and the European Academy of Orthokeratology and Myopia Control.

Thibaud had a passion for designing custom geometries for Rigid Gas Permeable (RGP) lenses. His skills are in high demand as he serves as a consultant for various contact lens manufacturers.

Furthermore, Thibaud is a respected keynote speaker at major congress throughout France, sharing his insights and advancements in the field of optometry with his peers and industry professionals.

[us_separator size=”large”]
[us_separator size=”small” show_line=”1″]
[us_post_navigation in_same_term=”1″]
[us_sharing providers=”facebook,twitter,linkedin” align=”right”]
Tags: , , , , , ,

Managing Bilateral Penetrating Keratoplasty-Related Rim Ectasia and Astigmatism

[us_post_title][us_post_date]

Introduction

This patient is a 51 YO female who had bilateral Penetrating Keratoplasties around 30 years ago in Rotterdam. Her grafts have become ectatic over the years and now exhibit signs of Rim Ectasia. This presents itself as a thinning of the host cornea leading to a tilting of the graft and a significant increase in irregular astigmatism.

[us_separator]
[us_image image=”10824″]

Right Topography 

[us_image image=”10823″]

Left Topography

[us_separator size=”small”]

Her current spectacle prescription is: 

R -2.50/-6.50×50              6/7.5 

L +1.25/-12.75×125         6/7.5- 

Her visual acuity with the spectacles is good but her occupation as a Paediatric Doctor means her glasses are an inconvenience and after seeing the Corneal Consultant, she was referred to me for a contact lens fitting. The amount of irregular astigmatism and the fact that the grafts are tilted forward superiorly means that even in a post-graft design, corneal GPs would be unsuitable. After a discussion with the patient, we decided to fit some mini-sclerals. The patient had previously worn full 22mm sclerals in the past and was receptive to the idea of mini-sclerals. 

Initial fitting appointment 16/4/21 

Trial with OneFit Med, Blanchard laboratory, Canada 

Several lenses were trialled before a pair of lenses were found which cleared the cornea in both eyes.  

The image below shows one of the lenses trialled with excessive clearance over the whole cornea, which illustrates the extent of the Rim Ectasia in this patient. 

[us_separator][us_image image=”10825″ align=”center”][us_separator size=”small”]

Finally, the 5450μ lens for the RE and the 5750μ for the LE were used.

  Right Eye Left Eye
Lens 5450 μ sag -10.00 toric periphery 150 μ 5750 μ sag -11.00 toric periphery 150 μ
O/R -2.50/-1.50×120 -4.00/-1.50×40
V/A 6/7.6++ 6/6-

The lenses were allowed to settle for 40 minutes before over-refraction and then OCT scanning was conducted using the MS-39 AS-OCT from CSO Italia, which produces a 16mm image size and can image the full diameter of the lens in situ.

The OCT images showed central clearance of R 175 μ and L 200 μ however there was a significant amount of touch in the 12 O’clock position on both eyes L>R.

The flat axes of the toric periphery aligned with the corneal astigmatism at R 120 and L 40 and were tight along these axes.

The lenses required an increased height at the areas of superior touch; with the OneFit Med this is achievable in two zones at 9.5mm and 12.5mm, the clearance at 12.5 was good so the M or mid-peripheral zones height would need to be increased by 100μ in each eye. The toricity would also need increasing, using the online calculator, the new parameters were calculated as follows:

R 5450μ -10.62/-1.50×120 200μ TP M +100μ

L 5750μ -13.12/-2.50×40   200μ TP M + 100μ

It is important to keep the central clearance as low as possible to maximise the oxygen reaching the cornea. For this reason, the lenses were manufactured in the Optimum Infinite material with a 180 Dk to minimise the risk of both Hypoxia and possible corneal decompensation.

Collection appointment 24/5/21

  Right Eye Left Eye
Lens 5450 -10.62/-1.50×120 5750 -13.12/-2.50×40
VA 6/7.6 6/7.6
BEO 6/6 6/6

AS-OCT showed no touch with 200μ of clearance centrally and 80μ of clearance at the M zone.

[us_separator][us_image image=”10826″ align=”center”][us_separator size=”small”]

Px was then instructed on insertion and removal, issued with Hy-Care, Saline, case and instructed to build up wearing time by 1 hour/day to a maximum of 10 hours until the next visit.

Follow-up visit 21/6/21

Wearing time today: 4 hours

  Right Eye Left Eye
Lens 5450 -10.62/-1.50×120 5750 -13.12/-1.50×40
M +100μ + 100μ
TP 200μ 200μ
VA 6/6- 6/7.6
OR -1.00 -1.00
VA -6/6 6/6
BEO 6/6- 6/6-

Scanning the patient with AS-OCT showed that the right lens had settled back and was now touching the superior cornea at approximately 2 o’clock slightly inside the central zone of the lens and caused some edge lift off superiorly.

Some increase in superior clearance was required without increasing the central clearance due to Hypoxia concerns with a thick fluid layer over the graft. The OneFit has a reverse geometry option called Central Clearance Reduction (CCR). This flattens the base curve of the optic zone diameter. In this instance, by using CCR, the flatter base curve lifts the lens away from the protruding graft and has the additional benefit of reducing some of the high minus in the lens power.

The calculator was used to produce the new lens specification taking into account the over-refraction and CCR on the right lens.

  Right Eye Left Eye
Lens 5450 -7.62/-1.50×120 5750 -14.12/-1.50×40
CCR 5450 -7.62/-1.50×120 5750 -14.12/-1.50×40
M +100μ +100μ
TP 200μ 200μ

The existing lenses were retained from the patient as it was too risky for her to keep wearing lenses with corneal touch particularly as it was near the graft/host margin.

Collection appointment 27/7/21

  Right Eye Left Eye
Lens 5450 -7.62/-1.50×120 5750 -14.12/1.50×5
VA 6/6++  6/4.8
Central Clearance 150μ 200μ
M Zone Clearance 85μ 125μ
Edges Aligned well in both eyes; no impingement seen Aligned well in both eyes; no impingement seen

Edges aligned well in both eyes; no impingement seen

The Patient was again instructed to build up the wearing time gradually by 1 hour per day to a maximum of 10 hours and 4-5 days/week.

Follow-up appointment 15/9/21

  Right Eye Left Eye
Lens 5450 -7.62/-1.50×120 5750 -14.12/-1.50×5
VA 6/6  6/6 +++
Clearance 85μ 65μ
TP 200μ 200μ

The patient had built up the wearing time to 5 hours per day 5 days a week which suited her working schedule. The lenses were fitting well with no adverse effects, she was put on a 3/12 recall, sooner if any issues or concerns.

Follow-up appointment 17/1/22

The patient is still happy with her lenses and is able to use them while exercising and scuba diving as well as some time at work. She finds her eyes become slightly red at about 7-8 hours so limits her time to less than that.

  Right Eye Left Eye
Lens -7.62/-1.50×120 5750 -14.12/-1.50×5
VA 6/6 +  6/4.8

The lenses are still clearing the cornea fully, no touch was observed in any meridian.

The corneal consultant has also seen the patient and is happy with her corneal health. She will be seen on a six-monthly review schedule in the contact lens clinic with the option for me to refer her to the corneal clinic if there are any concerns.

[us_separator show_line=”1″ size=”small”]
[us_post_navigation in_same_term=”1″]
[us_sharing providers=”facebook,twitter,linkedin” align=”right”]
Tags: , , , , ,

Type 1 Lattice Corneal Dystrophy Status Post Penetrating Keratoplasty: A Scleral Lens Success Story

[us_post_title][us_post_date]

By Sharon Qiu OD MS

Background 

Type 1 lattice corneal dystrophy (LCD1) is a rare hereditary bilateral disorder of the cornea. This is a result of an autosomal dominant mutation of the TGFBI (transforming growth factor beta induced) gene which leads to accumulation of amyloid deposits in stroma1

Variable clinical appearance depends on the stage of the disease2

  • At the onset (usually by age 10): small filamentous anterior stromal lesions, mostly central
  • With progression: lesions affect posterior stroma and opacify, eventually assuming a ground glass appearance throughout the cornea
  • By the third decade: most patients will experience recurrent corneal erosions (RCEs) and reduced visual acuity (VA)

Diagnosis:

  • Biomicroscopy examination alone is often sufficient to diagnose LCD1
  • Corneal biopsy: can be used for definitive diagnosis3

Treatment: RCE management, phototherapeutic keratectomy and penetrating keratoplasty (PKP) in later stages3

Case Description – Patient MF 

64-year-old Caucasian female, diagnosis of LCD1 OU confirmed by corneal biopsy with a corneal specialist.

Past surgical history

The patient had penetrating keratoplasty (PKP) OD in 2016, and cataract extraction (CE) OU (OD 2015, OS 2022).

Chief complaint

MF complained of blurred vision OU with PALs despite PKP OD, in addition to difficulty adjusting to new glasses since OS CE a few months prior.

Habitual glasses Rx with VA

OD -4.75-6.25×075 20/30- (PH 20/20-)

OS plano                      20/50    (PH NI)

Add +2.50 

Topography

OD tilted corneal graft with inferior elevation and steepening (Figure 1)

OS irregular astigmatism (Figure 2)

[us_separator size=”small”]
[us_image image=”10832″ align=”center”]
[us_image image=”10833″]

Figure 1: Topography of right eye at initial consultation visit

[us_separator]
[us_image image=”10834″]
[us_image image=”10835″]

Figure 2: Topography of left eye at initial consultation visit

[us_separator size=”small”]
Slit lamp examination of cornea

OD: tilted corneal graft with inferior elevation, clear centrally (Figure 3)

OS: hazy ground glass-like lesions involving anterior and posterior stroma from limbus to limbus (Figure 4)

[us_separator size=”small”][us_image image=”10836″ align=”center”]

Figure 3: anterior segment photo of right eye wearing a scleral lens

[us_separator size=”small”][us_image image=”10837″ align=”center”]

Figure 4: anterior segment photo of left eye showing lattice dystrophy

[us_separator size=”small”]

Scleral Lens Management OD

A Onefit MED scleral lens (Blanchard Contact Lenses) was ordered for OD only

Parameters

4300 / 7.78 / -5.37 / 15.6 / M-100 / L +25 / TPC +25/-125 / Optimum Infinite / 0.20

Two-week follow-up

BCVA OD: 20/20-

Excellent fitting relationship (Figures 5 and 6): central clearance of 210 μm after 4 hours of wear, good mid-peripheral and limbal clearance 360, edges aligned 360.

Patient reported clear and comfortable vision all day OD. 

[us_separator size=”small”][us_image image=”10838″ align=”center”]

Figure 5: AS-OCT image of right eye wearing a scleral lens at two-week follow-up: excellent fitting relationship from limbus to limbus

[us_separator size=”small”][us_image image=”10839″ align=”center”]

Figure 6: AS-OCT of right eye wearing a scleral lens at two-week follow-up: central clearance of 210 μm after 4 hours of wear

[us_separator size=”small”]

Discussions 

For patients with advanced LCD1, scleral lenses can offer superior vision and comfort after PKP. Scleral lenses may improve vision in an eye with corneal dystrophy: significant improvement in BCVA (0.492 logMAR) in a study with 17 eyes with corneal dystrophy.4 However, patient MF was already considering having PKP done on OS before scleral lens fitting, due to having worse BCVA OS post-CE compared to pre-CE. When only one eye has undergone PKP, scleral lens fitting success in the post-operative eye can help accelerate the decision to operate on the other eye.

[us_separator show_line=”1″ size=”small”]
1. Afshari NA, Mullally JE, Afshari MA, Steinert RF, Adamis AP, Azar DT, Talamo JH, Dohlman CH, Dryja TP. Survey of patients with granular, lattice, avellino, and Reis-Bücklers corneal dystrophies for mutations in the BIGH3 and gelsolin genes. Arch Ophthalmol. 2001 Jan;119(1):16-22. PMID: 11146721.
2. Weis JS et al. The IC3D Classification of the Corneal Dystrophies. Cornea Volume 27, Suppl. 2, December 2008
3. Klintworth, Gordon K. Corneal dystrophies. Orphanet journal of rare diseases vol. 4 7. 23 Feb. 2009, doi:10.1186/1750-1172-4-7
4. Parra AS, Roth BM, Nguyen TM, Wang L, Pflugfelder SC, Al-Mohtaseb Z. Assessment of the prosthetic replacement of ocular surface ecosystem (prose) scleral lens on visual acuity for corneal irregularity and ocular surface disease. The Ocular Surface. 2018;16(2):254–8.
[us_separator show_line=”1″ size=”small”]
[us_image image=”10873″ size=”us_600_600_crop” has_ratio=”1″ ratio=”3×4″]

Sharon Qiu, OD, MS is a residency-trained optometrist with a passion for specialty contact lenses. She completed an OD/MS dual degree at the New England College of Optometry, where she graduated as the valedictorian of the Class of 2022. After graduation, Dr. Qiu completed a residency in Cornea and Contact Lenses at the University of Waterloo. Dr. Qiu is currently pursuing a full-time PhD in Vision Science at the University of Waterloo Centre for Ocular Research & Education (CORE). She is also serving as a part-time attending optometrist and supervisor for 4th year student interns at the University of Waterloo Contact Lens and Myopia Control Clinic. Her ultimate goal is to become a clinician scientist. She aspires to make a positive impact on her patients’ life, both at an individual level as a clinician, and at a global level as a researcher.

[us_separator size=”small” show_line=”1″]
[us_post_navigation in_same_term=”1″]
[us_sharing providers=”facebook,twitter,linkedin” align=”right”]
Tags: , , , , ,

Not a Steep Learning Curve

[us_post_title]

Using OC-SAG Data to Assess the Suitability For Soft Lens Wear

[us_post_date]

By Gerard Smits

Introduction

This lens fit appears like a complex case, with at least three different factors playing a role. But by ‘simply’ applying a basic set of rules, this case report shows what a difference an Eye Care Professional (ECP) can make in people’s lives. First, by assessing whether an eye is ‘standard’ or not, the ECP can determine whether one of our standard off-the-shelf lenses would be the best lens option, with many benefits including material choice, pricing and – especially – frequency of replacement. ‘Simply’ because the ocular surface is steep and outside the range of the normal eye, choosing a ‘steep lens’ based on sagittal height can make the difference. In addition, there is the challenge (or not) of the lens prescription and material considerations. Not that complicated at all, and, in fact, without a steep learning curve.

Subjective

Tessa came to our practice right in the heart of Amsterdam in the Netherlands. Her prescription is out-of-standard. The feasibility of a standard monthly lens is explored but was questioned. With her high hyperopic prescription, the cosmetic and visual effects of contact lenses over glasses should not be ignored (large visible eyes, aberrations, magnification and sub-optimal visual acuity with glasses).

In the past, she had tried different lens types, with a long track record including, but not limited to Durasoft 3 (Wesley Jessen), Unilab 42C toric (Taiwan) and StabMax (MicroLens). Reproducibility used to be a major problem in the past with custom-made lenses; a problem that has been mostly relegated with current manufacturing techniques. The patient history did not reveal any special or specific considerations or limitations for fitting with a soft lens, other than that she reported having mild dry eyes.

Objective

General slit lamp examination revealed no abnormalities. Refraction of the patient (in this case report we focus on her right eye) came down to: S+4.75=C -5.00 x 90°. Her sim-K values are 7.36/7.14, with eccentricities reported in four different quadrants as: 0.45 superior, 0.71 nasal, 0.58 inferior and 0.35 temporal.

In our contact lens practice, special emphasis is on the shape of the anterior ocular surface. We use a Medmont corneal topographer with a special tool: the E-H software*. Based on the overall corneal topography using that instrument, the peripheral corneal angle measured with the corneal topographer and using the sagittal height calculator – the overall sagittal height of the ocular surface (OC-SAG) over 15mm can be estimated, typically the horizontal meridian values are used.

Assessment

In this case, the E-H 0-180° value was 4097µm. This is well beyond the OC-SAG of the average eye (which is estimated to be in the 3750µm range). In fact, it falls outside the one-standard deviation range (between 3550-3950µm). The fact that this eye falls on the right side of the normal distribution bell curve and even outside the 1-SD range (accountable for 66.7% of all eyes) – indicates that this is an out-of-standard steep eye. Based on keratometry values alone (7.36/7.14), and even in combination with the eccentricity values this time (0.53, which is standard), it is not easy to judge that in the same way. Her corneal diameter (white-to-white) measured with the Medmont was 11.2mm which is slightly smaller than normal.

In addition, the prescription’s astigmatism does not match the corneal astigmatism data (the difference in central keratometry values is only 0.22mm, which represents roughly an astigmatism of 1 diopter, while the refraction indicates 5 diopters of astigmatism). The refractive (rest) cylinder must therefore come from the crystalline lens or another internal astigmatism in the eye.

[us_separator size=”small”][us_image image=”10692″ align=”center”]

Plan

For this patient, it was decided not to start with standard lenses but go directly to an out-of-standard lens – to satisfy both the refractive and ocular surface shape peculiarities of this patient’s eye.

With any toric lens, but certainly, with an astigmatism of this magnitude, good stabilization of the lens on-eye is crucial. Fitting a toric lens is not a disadvantage, in this case, though – but rather an advantage. Since most soft toric lenses have their toricity based on the inside of the lens – this can help stabilization with higher cylindrical values. In other words: a 5D cylinder stabilizes better most probably than a 0.75D cylinder.

In addition, ECPs can choose to fit a slightly steeper lens, to aid stability of the lens on-eye and/or to choose a larger diameter. But for this, it is important to know how steep the eye is. This cannot be judged by central keratometry values and/or eccentricity alone, as this case shows. The eye is exceptionally steep, and to create stability an even steeper lens would be needed. A 7.70 lens was selected in the end, with a lens diameter that is not larger than normal (because of her corneal diameter). But the result is a lens with an out-of-standard high sagittal height value. Using sagittal height values, in this case, makes more sense than using base curve values. 

A Gentle 80 Toric (Mark’Ennovy, Madrid ES) was used in this case: BC 7.70 S+5.00=C -5.00 x 95° Æ14.0. This is an 80% hydrogel lathe-cut soft lens for monthly replacement. The lens with these parameters is calculated to have a CL-SAG of 4100µm. This material, a non-silicone hydrogel (SH) material was preferred over the silicone hydrogel lathe-cut soft lens variant (Saphir Rx ) for monthly replacement, because of wettability issues with the SH lens material.

In Summary

It can be determined that there are 3 categories of soft lenses:

(1) off-the-rack standard soft lenses; 

(2) out-of-standard lenses with extended parameters;

(3) custom-made individually designed lenses. 

For patients like this, the number 1 category is out of range.

First: the refraction is out of the standard lens’ parameter range. In these cases, category 2 lenses can be a huge asset and can prevent drop-out of lens wear. In this case, it was not just a special optical case, but also an ocular surface shape outlier: an exceptionally ‘steep’ eye that desired a special design with a higher-than-normal CL-SAG. Both optically, and in terms of lens comfort, this lens performs better than previous lenses. As a third variable, the silicone hydrogel lenses originally selected did not provide the desired wettability. Switching to a non-SH solved this problem. Careful checks for hypoxic signs on the eye are monitored. But having the option to switch material, whilst staying in the same lens design – can be a huge plus for ECPs when fitting soft specialty lenses.

This case shows that, albeit ‘complex’ at first, applying simple rules towards (1) eye shape, (2) prescription and (3) material properties can make a big difference in contact lens practice.

*the E-H tool in the Medmont topographer can be added simply, using the manufacturers guidelines.

This case study is part of a series focusing on speciality soft lens fitting. Stay tuned for the next installment coming soon. Special thanks to Eef van der Worp for bringing this series together.

[us_separator show_line=”1″ size=”small”]
[us_image image=”10495″ size=”us_600_600_crop” has_ratio=”1″ ratio=”3×4″]

Gerard comes from a long line of opticians (grandparents, father and brother are all opticians). He graduated from the Christiaan Huygenschool (optics) in Rotterdam, and started working as a contact lens specialist in 1985. Since then he has been a member of the ANVC (Dutch Contact Lens Association). He has specialized in both rigid and soft lens fitting and has worked as a consultant for many industry partners, and tested different (specialty) lenses in his practice for the industry. He works as Ralph Optiek in the center of Amsterdam. His experience includes specialty lenses, such as orthokeratology, rigid corneal lenses after refractive surgery and fitting of custom soft lenses. Customization of lens fiting using corneal topography data and multifocal (rigid corneal and soft) lens fitting are two of the main challenges, but also opportunities he sees for your profession.

[us_separator size=”small” show_line=”1″]
[us_post_navigation in_same_term=”1″]
[us_sharing providers=”facebook,twitter,linkedin” align=”right”]
Tags: , , , , , ,

Avoiding a Corneal Transplant in a Young Patient

[us_post_title][us_post_date]

By William Skoog OD, FAAO

Affiliations: Illinois College of Optometry

Background

Corneal opacity is the fifth leading cause of blindness worldwide¹. A common cause of corneal opacity is infectious keratitis. In developed countries, contact lenses are the leading cause of infectious keratitis while in developing countries it is from corneal trauma during agriculture work¹. The most common organism responsible for microbial keratitis in contact lens wear is Pseudomonas aeruginosa². When the visual axis is involved, a cornea transplant may be required to improve vision. Corneal transplants have a higher rate of rejection in younger patients³. 

Case Description

A 19-year-old Hispanic female presented for a gas permeable contact lens fitting. Her ocular history was remarkable for microbial keratitis OS caused by Pseudomonas following extended wear of an unknown monthly soft contact lens. 

Entering visual acuities were 20/20 OD with correction and 20/200 OS without correction which improved to 20/40 with pinhole. All other entrance testing was unremarkable.

Slit lamp examination revealed a 6 mm round, central stromal scar with significant stromal thinning OS (Figure 1). 

Simulated keratometry measurements were taken from tomography and were 40.75/43.0 @ 89 OD (Figure 2), 33.75/35.50 @ 99 OS (Figure 3). 

Manifest Refraction was -7.00-1.50×170 OD with a distance acuity of 20/20 and +2.00 sphere OS with a distance acuity of 20/80. 

Due to the decrease in VA secondary to a central corneal opacity a diagnostic scleral lens was applied to the left eye to determine visual potential. The initial diagnostic lens that was applied to OS was a prolate lens (Table 1A) that showed excessive central fluid reservoir clearance (Figure 4A). Her VA improved to 20/30 with an over-refraction. Since there was a vast improvement in VA with a scleral lens, the decision was made to peruse wearing a scleral lens OS. The final lens order was changed to an oblate design (Table 1B) which improved the central fluid reservoir clearance (Figure 4B). 

Optimum Extreme, a high-DK material was selected to allow the compromised cornea to receive as much oxygen as possible while she was wearing the lens. Since the initial corneal insult happened because of non-compliance, the importance of contact lens hygiene, wearing schedule, cleaning regimen and proper filling solution was discussed at length with her and her parents. 

She was closely followed over the first three months of scleral lens wear to ensure appropriate wear.

[us_separator size=”small”][us_image image=”10663″ size=”us_600_0″ align=”center”]

Figure 1: Slit lamp photo showing a 6mm round central stromal scar OS secondary to microbial keratitis.

[us_separator]
[us_image image=”10665″ size=”us_600_0″ align=”center”]

Figure 2: Axial map showing with-the-rule astigmatism in the right eye.

[us_image image=”10664″ size=”us_600_0″ align=”center”]

Figure 3: Axial map showing central corneal flattening secondary to microbial keratitis in the left eye.

[us_separator]
[us_image image=”10666″ size=”us_600_0″ align=”center”]

Figure 4A: An AS-OCT of a prolate diagnostic scleral lens OS showing excessive central vault with adequate mid-peripheral vault.

[us_image image=”10667″ align=”center” size=”us_600_0″]

Figure 4B: An AS-OCT of an oblate scleral lens design OS showing adequate central clearance after ~6 hours of wear.

[us_separator]
Type Power BC Diameter Edge Design
Onefit 2.0 Plano 8.4 14.9 std Prolate

Table 1A. Initial diagnostic scleral lens OS that showed excessive central clearance

[us_separator]
Type Power BC Diameter Edge Design Material
Onefit 2.0 +6.50 8.4 14.9 std Oblate – CCR 230 Optimum Extreme

Table 1B. Final scleral lens design OS 

[us_separator size=”small”]

Conclusions

Corneal scarring after microbial keratitis leads to vision loss secondary to corneal opacity and irregular astigmatism⁴. The two most common options to improve vision in these cases are corneal transplantation or a specialty contact lens. Corneal gas permeable or scleral contact lenses should be considered if they are able to provide the patient with functional vision as was demonstrated in this case.

[us_separator show_line=”1″ size=”small”]
1. Ting, D.S.J., Ho, C.S., Deshmukh, R. et al. Infectious keratitis: an update on epidemiology, causative microorganisms, risk factors, and antimicrobial resistance. Eye 35, 1084–1101 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41433-020-01339-3
2. Tan, S., Walkden, A., Au, L. et al. Twelve-year analysis of microbial keratitis trends at a UK tertiary hospital. Eye 31, 1229–1236 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1038/eye.2017.55
3. Gulias-Cañizo R, Gonzalez-Salinas R, Hernandez-Zimbron LF, Hernandez-Quintela E, Sanchez-Huerta V. Indications and outcomes of pediatric keratoplasty in a tertiary eye care center: A retrospective review. Medicine (Baltimore). 2017 Nov;96(45):e8587. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000008587. PMID: 29137083; PMCID: PMC5690776.
4. Singh K, Jain D, Teli K. Rehabilitation of vision disabling corneal opacities: is there hope without corneal transplant? Cont Lens Anterior Eye. 2013 Apr;36(2):74-9. doi: 10.1016/j.clae.2012.10.085. Epub 2012 Nov 27. PMID: 23199902.
[us_separator show_line=”1″ size=”small”]
[us_image image=”10662″ size=”us_600_600_crop” has_ratio=”1″]

Dr. Skoog is a clinical instructor at the Illinois College of Optometry in the cornea and contact lens department, where he previously completed a residency. He lectures on anterior segment disease and contact lenses. He has no disclosures.

[us_separator size=”large”]
[us_separator size=”small” show_line=”1″]
[us_post_navigation in_same_term=”1″]
[us_sharing providers=”facebook,twitter,linkedin” align=”right”]
Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Stage 1 Keratoconus: Great Visual Acuity with Custom Soft Contact Lens

[us_post_title][us_post_date]

by Marianne Lindenberg

Introduction

Traditionally, gas permeable, scleral and even hybrid contact lenses are recommended for patients with keratoconus or other diseases that cause irregularity of the cornea, as they can effectively correct the significant levels of astigmatism through neutralization by the tear film. However, there is evidence to support the use of custom-made soft contact lenses designed for keratoconus in the management of this condition. These lenses are designed to conform to the irregular shape of the cornea while providing improved visual acuity (VA) and good comfort. 

This case report presents the successful use of custom-made soft contact lenses in a patient with keratoconus, highlighting the benefits and potential advantages of this lens type in the management of this condition.

Subjective

This clinical account relates to a 27-year-old Caucasian male patient who was diagnosed with bilateral keratoconus. Following the diagnosis, the patient was recommended to start wearing contact lenses to reach better visual acuity. The patient was subsequently seen in our clinic approximately one-month post-diagnosis for the fitting of contact lenses.  

Upon initial evaluation at our clinic, the patient reported experiencing a gradual decline in visual acuity over the past year, with worse visual acuity in his left eye. The patient also reported frequent itching in both eyes, which was accompanied by a habit of excessive eye rubbing. Despite the itchiness, the patient denied a history of hay fever or other allergic conditions, though they did report sensitivity to perfumes in soap-like products. The patient reported no significant medical history or current medication usage.

When evaluating a patient with a medical condition who is referred for contact lens management, it is our standard practice to gather information regarding their perceptions and expectations of contact lens wear in order to make an informed decision on the most appropriate lens type for the individual. During the consultation, the patient expressed concern regarding the potential discomfort associated with contact lens wear, specifically related to pain, increased itchiness, and stinging from solution.

Objective

Spectacles (2021) OD S-3.50=C-0.50×105 OS S-2.75=C-0.25×178
VA with specs OD 0.9 OS 0.6
AR OD S-3.50=C-0.75×74 OS S-1.75=C-1.50×137
VA with AR  OD 0.9 OS 0.7
Slit-lamp Ectasia OS>OD, (-) striae, (-) Fleischer, (-) Munson sign
Funduscopy Healthy aspect OU
Pentacam
[us_separator size=”small”]
[us_image image=”10560″]
[us_image image=”10561″]
[us_separator size=”small”]

Assessment

Analysis of the collected data leads to the conclusion that the left eye experiences a greater level of visual deficit compared to the right eye. This observation is in agreement with the results obtained from a Pentacam tomographic analysis, which reveals steeper central K readings and a greater degree of corneal irregularity in the left eye. Although the left eye presents as more advanced compared to the right eye, both eyes are classified as stage 1 according to the Amsler-Krumeich grading system.

Considering that this patient expresses a negative attitude towards contact lenses, and rigid lenses may give firm discomfort in the beginning, this could result in a reluctance to wear contact lenses, despite improved vision compared to spectacles. To mitigate this, fitting the patient with soft contact lenses may be a more suitable solution.

In the past, fitting a keratoconic patient with soft contact lenses was not an efficacious strategy, as the soft lenses would conform to the irregular shape of the cornea. For this reason, vision correction with regular soft contact lenses did not yield an improvement beyond that achievable with spectacles. However, in the past years, there have been remarkable improvements in the design of soft contact lenses for treating keratoconus. These custom-made custom lenses are useful for correcting the early stages of keratoconus, for individuals with decentered cones, and for those who cannot tolerate rigid lenses. 

The Kerasoft IC lens by Ultravision is one of the available lenses in this category. This design offers balanced overall thickness with spherical aberration control. It is advised to use a diagnostic fitting lens to evaluate the fit and determine the appropriate power of the lens. Following the fitting guide, the diagnostic lens with BCR 8.6 and a standard periphery was tried. Refraction was performed over the contact lens within 5 minutes of its insertion, yielding an over-refraction of OD S-3.25=C-1.00×45 & OS S-2.25=C-0.75×155, resulting in a corrected visual acuity of 1.2 OU, and 1.0 with OD and OS. The fit of the right lens was deemed adequate, while the left lens fit tightly at the edges. The laser mark on both lenses was correctly oriented.

Plan

The patient expressed a very positive reaction to the comfort of the contact lenses and was happy with the improvement of his visual acuity. He made the decision to commence wearing contact lenses. Hence the tight fit for the left eye and the over-refraction of the following contact lenses were prescribed for this patient:  

OD Kerasoft IC / BCR 8.6 / S-3.25=C-1.00×45 / periphery standard / diam. 14.5
OS Kerasoft IC / BCR 8.6 / S-2.25=C-0.75×155 / periphery flat 1 / diam. 14.5

In Summary

Custom-made soft contact lenses with a special design can be helpful for people with keratoconus and provide a unique solution for those with irregular cornea shapes. The VA with these lenses is better than with spectacles in contradiction to the VA with regular soft contact lenses. These contact lenses should be considered as a way to manage keratoconus for individuals with early stages of keratoconus or decentered cones, and for those who cannot tolerate rigid lenses. 

This case study is part of a series focusing on speciality soft lens fitting. Stay tuned for the next installment coming soon. Special thanks to Eef van der Worp for bringing this series together.

[us_separator show_line=”1″ size=”small”]
[us_image image=”10563″ size=”us_600_600_crop” has_ratio=”1″]

Marianne Lindenberg is a Dutch optometrist. She specializes in fitting medical contact lenses for patients with a variety of eye conditions. Currently she practices at Oculenti Contactlenzen. In addition to her clinical work, Marianne serves as an independent professional affairs consultant for Johnson & Johnson, where she shares her expertise with other eye care professionals. Marianne is also a member of the research group of the Netherlands Contact Lens Congress (NCC).

[us_separator size=”small” show_line=”1″]
[us_post_navigation in_same_term=”1″]
[us_sharing providers=”facebook,twitter,linkedin” align=”right”]

Using a Customized Soft Lens

[us_post_title]

Sometimes ‘flat out’ the best option for a flat eye

[us_post_date]

By Gerard Smits

Introduction

The vast majority of the lenses we fit in contact lens practice are soft lenses. The amount of attention that goes into ‘fitting’ soft lenses is limited in contrast to the focus on scleral lens fitting, corneal lens fitting, and orthokeratology, for instance. This case shows how taking control of the fitting process can sometimes enhance someone’s life and upgrade one’s vision in relation to quality of life. 

Subjective

Mary came to our practice right in the heart of Amsterdam in the Netherlands. Her wish was to wear lenses in addition to the glasses that she used, with a preference for daily disposables if possible. The anamneses did not reveal any specific considerations or limitations for fitting with a soft lens. Patient complains of moderate dry eye symptoms.

Objective

General slit lamp examination revealed no abnormalities. We focus on the right eye of the patient for this case report. Refraction of the right eye came down to S+2.75, with a corneal diameter (white-to-white with the Medmont topographer) of 12.0mm with an overall average eccentricity of over four quadrants of 0.43.

In our contact lens practice, emphasis is on the shape of the entire anterior ocular surface, not just the central cornea. We use a Medmont corneal topographer for this reason, but with a special tool: the E-H software¹. 

Based on the overall corneal topography using that instrument, combined with the peripheral corneal angle measured with the topographer and using the sagittal height calculator – the overall sagittal height of the ocular surface (OC-SAG) over 15mm can be estimated, typically the horizontal meridian values are used.

In this case, the E-H 0-180° value 3524 microns. This figure is well below the OC-SAG of the average eye, which is estimated to be in the 3750 micron range. This eye also falls outside the one-standard deviation range (1-SD), which is between 3550-3950 microns.  

[us_separator][us_image image=”10467″ size=”us_768_0″ align=”center”][us_separator]

Assessment

The fact that this eye falls outside (on the left side) of the normal distribution bell-curve and even outside the 1-SD range – indicates that this is an exceptionally flat eye. Based on keratometry values alone (8.09/7.88) it is not easy to make the same judgement, especially as the eye has an average e-value and standard corneal diameter. In cases like this, measuring the full ocular surface over at least the diameter of the soft lens (or the benchmark 15mm is used as a standard often) can be very insightful. 

For this patient, several standard soft lenses were tried, including Dailies Aqua Comfort Plus (Alcon) BC 8.70 Ø 14.0, Clariti 1 Day (CooperVision) BC 8.60 Ø 14.1, Dailies All Day Comfort BC 8.60 Ø 13.80 and monthly disposable Biofinity (Alcon) BC8.60 Ø 14.0 and Fresh Excellent (Microlens/Wölk) BC 8.3 Ø 13.6. All lenses failed because of lack of movement and mobility, in addition to poor comfort.

Plan

Patient ultimately was refitted with a custom soft lens based on the patient’s corneal topography. The Medmont file was­­­ uploaded to the manufacturer and an individual monthly disposable silicone hydrogel lens was created for this patient. The Indivisual (Menicon, Emmen NL) was manufactured in the Definitive 74 material (Efrofilcon A V3) with a sagittal height of the lens (CL-SAG) of 2900 micron and a tangential peripheral shape (tangent angle 54°) S+2.50 in a Ø 14.1. 

The lens design is similar to how many scleral lens designs are configured these days. The lens fit procedure would also be close to fitting a scleral lens: changing the tangent angle would ‘lift’ the lens, decreasing the lens to a lower sagittal height. For this patient, this lens design resulted in an optimal lens fit with excellent movement – which is believed to be the result of the tangential peripheral shape of the lens in conjunction with the customized CL-SAG height. 

In Summary

Using the overall sagittal height of the ocular surface over a 15mm chord can give the eye care practitioner (ECP) valuable information about when to start with a flat or steep lens (a low or high CL-SAG) using the Pacific University SAG-charts, or when to divert to an out-of standard or a customized lens – like in this case. This will save time, on behalf of the patient and the ECP, from fewer trial lenses used and increased overall satisfaction. Consequently, this can potentially prevent drop-out of soft lens wear. 

The initial lens type requested by the patient, daily disposables, come in a variety of brands but are limited in size and parameters. It is the task of the ECP to assess and decide which lens is suitable for a given eye and which is not. This case perfectly illustrates the decision-making process, and a custom-made lens in a silicone hydrogel material with a monthly replacement schedule is the ideal solution for the patient. The patient still desires a daily disposable lens, if possible, but that is not feasible in this case. As ECPs we must be clear about this. In regard to the patient’s complaint of moderate dry eye symptoms – as ECPs we must be careful with that. Any form and type of eye discomfort can be easily mistaken for dry eye. But often, lens fit pro­­blems are partially or fully the root cause of discomfort issues, and lens fit issues need to be addressed first. The ‘take-home message’ in this case was pretty obvious: a flat lens for this flat eye was the best technical option for this patient.  

¹the E-H tool in the Medmont topographer can be added simply, using the manufacturer’s guidelines. 

This case study is part of a series focusing on speciality soft lens fitting. Stay tuned for the next installment coming soon. Special thanks to Eef van der Worp for bringing this series together.

[us_separator show_line=”1″ size=”small”]
[us_image image=”10495″ size=”us_600_0″ has_ratio=”1″ ratio=”3×4″]
[us_separator size=”small”]

Gerard comes from a long line of opticians (grandparents, father and brother are all opticians). He graduated from the Christiaan Huygenschool (optics) in Rotterdam, and started working as a contact lens specialist in 1985. Since then he has been a member of the ANVC (Dutch Contact Lens Association). He has specialized in both rigid and soft lens fitting and has worked as a consultant for many industry partners, and tested different (specialty) lenses in his practice for the industry. He works as Ralph Optiek in the center of Amsterdam. His experience includes specialty lenses, such as orthokeratology, rigid corneal lenses after refractive surgery and fitting of custom soft lenses. Customization of lens fiting using corneal topography data and multifocal (rigid corneal and soft) lens fitting are two of the main challenges, but also opportunities he sees for your profession.

[us_separator size=”small” show_line=”1″]
[us_post_navigation in_same_term=”1″]
[us_sharing providers=”facebook,twitter,linkedin” align=”right”]
Tags: , , , , , , ,

The Soft Lens Dropout Patient – Part 2

[us_post_title][us_post_date][us_image size=”us_600_0″ image=”10266″ align=”center”]

by Martin Conway

For those readers who may not have read the first part of this article here’s a brief recap:

I have been describing the case of a typical soft lens dropout patient, Natasha, who works in the office and kindly agreed to participate in our investigation. She would dearly like to wear contact lenses for social and family occasions and particularly when she watches her favourite sport, rugby.

Previously, she found she could only wear her lenses for 3-4 hours, which meant taking them out halfway through a day out, such as at a family wedding or when watching a game.

Initially, she had a tear break-up time (TBUT) of 2.5 seconds, so we instigated some remedial treatments such as warm compresses, lid massage and lid wipes.

Read Part One of the Soft Lens Dropout Patient.

[us_image image=”9932″ size=”us_600_600_crop” align=”center”]

Follow-up Assessment

Natasha continued with her routine of warm compresses and lid massage, together with Tea Tree Lid Wipes – which turned out to be her preferred choice from the selection I offered her.

Her eyes felt better – particularly after the Warm Compress – and the TBUT has improved from just 2.5 seconds to over 7 seconds in the Right Eye and nearly 7 seconds in the Left (Fig 1 and 2).

[us_image size=”us_600_0″ image=”10267″ align=”center”][us_image image=”10268″ size=”us_600_0″ align=”center”][us_text text=”Fig 1 and 2: Non-Invasive Break-Up Time (NIBUT) Right and Left” css=”%7B%22default%22%3A%7B%22text-align%22%3A%22center%22%2C%22font-size%22%3A%2212px%22%7D%7D”]

But what of her Contact Lens Wear?

I wasn’t sure what type of lens Natasha had been offered previously, so for this exercise, I thought we should start with a basic hydrogel from a known supplier rather than a more complex silicone hydrogel and surface treatments. 

If you recall from the first instalment of this saga, Natasha struggled to manage 3-4 hours of wear with earlier attempts at soft lens wear. This meant needing to remove lenses halfway through family events or rugby matches due to discomfort.

Using a 59% water content moulded lens, Natasha managed to wear the lenses for nearly 7 hours without discomfort, only removing them when she got home rather than out of necessity.

The TBUT score is still below what is typically considered sufficient to maintain regular wear, so we will continue the treatment and see if we can continue to improve. 

I think this shows that motivated patients can be fitted with lenses if the practitioner is willing to offer the correct advice and treatment. In this case, the patient, Natasha, was motivated partly because she wanted to wear contact lenses for days out with her family, but also because the treatment made her eyes more comfortable even when she was not wearing lenses.

Next Steps

We will continue to monitor the progress and in the next article will report on whether a more complex lens made from a silicone hydrogel with surface modifications can further improve comfort and wearing time, or whether we should progress to a customised option.

[us_separator show_line=”1″ size=”small”]
[us_image image=”8848″]
 
Martin Conway has over 40 years’ experience in the contact lens field as a qualified Contact Lens Optician. He is registered with the UK General Optical Council on the Speciality Contact Lens Register. Martin is a fellow of the British Contact Lens Association (FBCLA), and The International Association of Contact Lens Educators (FIACLE). He has served in the Professional Services role as an educator and clinical adviser on behalf of both Sauflon and CIBA, and now acts as Professional Services Consultant for Contamac. Martin has lectured extensively in Europe, Asia, Russia, North and South America and the Middle East.
[us_separator size=”small” show_line=”1″]
[us_post_navigation in_same_term=”1″]
[us_sharing providers=”facebook,twitter,linkedin” align=”right”]
Tags: , , , ,

The Soft Lens Dropout Patient – Part 1

[us_post_title][us_post_date][us_image image=”9956″ size=”us_600_0″ align=”center”]

By Martin Conway

Could a “Soft Lens Dropout” be a potential patient for the Speciality Lens Practitioner?

Patient dropout and the reasons for it have long since been a subject of discussion within both the contact lens industry and profession. Speciality lens manufacturers normally supply lenses for patients who are perhaps more motivated than those who simply seek a cosmetic alternative to spectacles, therefore this topic doesn’t seem to be a subject for discussion at speciality lens meetings. The average keratoconus patient, for example, will tend to be more tolerant of occasional, or even constant, discomfort if the alternative is no vision and therefore no driving, no work and all that follows! As an industry, we have traditionally concentrated our efforts on supplying lenses that fall outside the range of mass-produced moulded lenses. High prescriptions, keratoconus, and other ectasia are our bread and butter. That market share, however, is gradually being eroded as the moulders extend their ranges and move into that space. More recently, myopia management associated with the use of ortho k lenses offered a boost to the speciality lens industry. With the use of ortho k lenses for children, a whole new arena opened up. The multinationals soon recognised the opportunity that this myopic pandemic presented, and we now have moulded, disposable options to compete within this growth market, and even spectacle lens manufacturers compete in this space. It might be wise, therefore, for us to take a look at the “Dropout” phenomenon that has plagued the disposable lens sector to see whether there is a potential market for a speciality lens solution for this perennial issue.

The “Dropout” Patient

Over the years, various studies have estimated the figure at anywhere between 18 and 30%. These are defined as patients that are supplied with lenses but drop out of lens wear at 6-12 months. I am convinced that a significant proportion of the supposed dropout figures consists of poorly motivated patients that were oversold the idea of contact lens wear as part of promotional activity in optical stores, so we should discount those, they were never really “in” to lenses in the first place. We really need to target those patients who would dearly like to have an alternative method of vision correction and who are prepared to put a little time and effort into attaining it. If those were just 25% of the dropout figures normally quoted, then that is a huge number for our industry. There have been many studies examining possible indicators that may predispose a prospective patient to be unsuitable for soft lens wear and although practitioners should conduct an evaluation of tear quality and associated functions before fitting a lens, little can be done to accurately predict the outcome until a lens is worn for a period of time. Indeed, if a practitioner were to try to advise a determined cosmetic lens wearer that they were unsuitable for lenses, they would probably simply find another practitioner. For a patient with an ectasia or ocular surface disease, it is easier to insist that they undertake some form of remedial action prior to commencement of fitting to improve tear quality and therefore improve both the experience and the chances of success in fitting. They consider this as part of their treatment process. A potential cosmetic wearer will still expect to try lenses for themselves, and although a practitioner might warn the patient of their concerns, most still allow the patient to evaluate some trial lenses for themselves, and provide an initial supply. These are future dropouts and our target market.

Case Study

Patient history

One such patient arrived in my clinic at Contamac recently and agreed to participate in a study. Natasha first tried lenses some ten years ago when she was in her late thirties, she is slightly myopic with no astigmatism and wants to be able to socialise, see at rugby matches, and wear fashionable sunglasses on holiday. As a receptionist, her low prescription (-1.00D) wasn’t an issue at work and around the home, so a supply of daily disposable soft lenses appeared to be the ideal option. Unfortunately, despite several attempts, she couldn’t tolerate them for more than 3-4 hours. This meant that at day-long social functions, such as a wedding, having to take them out after the photographs and wearing spectacles in the evening. Her last practitioner had correctly diagnosed a dry eye problem and left her with the impression that nothing could be done, and she might even cause damage if she were to wear lenses.

[us_image image=”9932″ size=”us_600_600_crop” align=”center”]

Case Studies are a regular feature in publications like Global Insight; normally they have been concluded and the practitioner is sharing their experiences with the benefit of hindsight. This case study will be slightly different in that it is currently in the beginning stages at the time of publications. At this stage, the outcome is not definite, and I propose to follow a course of treatment as the case unfolds and report findings along the way.

Initial Assessment

[us_image image=”9933″ align=”center”][us_image image=”9934″ align=”center”]

Fig 1 and 2: Non-Invasive Break-Up Time (NIBUT) Right and Left

I first decided to assess the scale of the problem. The Medmont has an excellent Non-Invasive Break-Up Time (NIBUT) feature and that measurement was a little concerning at 2,5 seconds for the right eye and 2,6 for the left! (Fig 1 and 2).

This feature is automatic and measures the time at which 25% of the visible tear film has broken up. The images show the tear film at the end of the process around 10 seconds when discomfort forced the patient to blink. With a NIBUT of 10 seconds being a “normal” measure, we can see the extent of the problem.

Lid margins showed no active infection, but some meibomian glands were blocked, (Fig 3).

Despite this, I ordered some hydrogel daily disposable lenses to be worn at work, so that I could monitor and observe fit, and get a measure of wearing time and, sure enough, at 3-4 hours they were irritating. Topography had shown the corneae to be on the flat side of normal, but otherwise, the fit was acceptable for the purpose intended.

Rather than simply try an array of different lenses as had previously been done, we agreed to try to improve tear quality as best we could before deciding upon the next course of action. Natasha is holding back one set of the trial lenses we had used for us to assess any improvement in wearing time and comfort once we have attained an improvement in tear break-up time.

[us_image image=”9935″ align=”center”]

Fig 3: Meibomian gland assessment showed no infection but some blocked glands.

I am fortunate in that Natasha works here at Contamac, and is therefore readily available for consultations. She is also a willing volunteer and as interested in the progress of our investigations as I am. I appreciate that, in the real world, patients often demand an immediate result and will not necessarily be prepared to put up with the efforts required to improve tear quality and achieve a satisfactory result.

Speaking of results, I think at this stage it is important to set what is a realistic target for the patient. For Natasha, it is not to be able to become a full-time wearer of contact lenses. It is to be able to have to option to be able to go without spectacles for eight hours or so to attend the functions I mentioned earlier.

Treatment

Hot compresses, lid massage and lid scrubs will be the first stage. No active infection is present so no need for anything more complex at this stage. We’ll assess in a couple of weeks and decide on the next course of action. If the tear quality is sufficiently improved, I propose to try the same lenses as in the previous trial and see if the lid treatment has improved the comfort and wearing time.

Next Steps

I’ll report progress in the next edition of Global Insight and then in successive editions as the case progresses.

If you have any comments or suggestions either now or along the way, feel free to contact me and we can include those suggestions in the next edition.

[us_separator show_line=”1″ size=”small”]
[us_image image=”8848″]

Martin Conway has over 40 years’ experience in the contact lens field as a qualified Contact Lens Optician. He is registered with the UK General Optical Council on the Speciality Contact Lens Register. Martin is a fellow of the British Contact Lens Association (FBCLA), and The International Association of Contact Lens Educators (FIACLE). He has served in the Professional Services role as an educator and clinical adviser on behalf of both Sauflon and CIBA, and now acts as Professional Services Consultant for Contamac. Martin has lectured extensively in Europe, Asia, Russia, North and South America and the Middle East.

[us_separator size=”small”]
[us_separator show_line=”1″ size=”small”]
[us_post_navigation in_same_term=”1″]
[us_sharing providers=”facebook,twitter,linkedin” align=”right”]
Tags: , , , ,